Wednesday, June 15, 2011

Is Your Organization Learning? PART III

Continuing from my previous post in part II - if an organization was a learning organization, which means it incorporated a learning culture, how would it be different?

Recall what I said earlier about a learning culture. A learning culture:
  • facilitates learning opportunities,
  • ensures effective learning from these learning opportunities,
  • applies the learning gained.
Here is what I mean by these terms:

Facilitating Learning Opportunities: It does not automatically translate into having a dedicated training department, team, or budget, although in my view organizations should give it a serious thought. It is about continuously learning from every interaction or a meeting we have or a task we do. It can be as dedicated as having a proper training team or as informal as two colleagues talking over a coffee machine. You can choose to be cynical, but my assessment is that about 60% of the learning opportunities that come your way are informal.

Which is not to belittle your training team by the way. My only thought on that would be that if you have a training infrastructure in place, respect that training infrastructure. Treat it as important as operations or sales or finance or HR for that matter (though I am not very sure if there are many companies where HR is at par with finance or sales or ops). Organizations tend to treat the training team as a cost center because returns are not immediately visible, or in some cases not defined. When layoffs happen, the training team is the first (and usually the most convenient) to receive the blow. Training rooms are used for other reasons (storage, operations etc). If I sound radical or orthodox, the reason is I believe that the apathy towards the training team is the first step that an organization takes towards not being a learning organization.

In short, it is okay not to have a training team and use informal means of training, but if you are going to have a training team, make sure it is respected and supported.

Ensuring Effective Learning: Consider this scenario: The senior management in an organization decides that it will be beneficial for its sales team to learn about the new sales program that the company has decided to incorporate. These are the reactions you might get:
  • A Junior Sales Executive: "Good time pass!"
  • Middle Level Sales Manager: "15 people in my team. One hour of learning. 15 hours of productivity loss".
Sounds familiar? Now if you were to go into the reasons for this the following scenario will happen. The ones taking the training will blame the training team for not creating an effective training. The training team will blame the lack of clarity on learning requirements and the tight deadlines which made them deliver whatever they had ready. In all of this, the intent the senior management had will be blurred, and ultimately lost. The net result is that the sales team will learn the sales program the hard way, through unpleasant experiences and negative feedback.

Of course there is another way to implement this program: Get the sales manager to learn the program and then coach her reports. However, again the intent is likely to get blurred and then lost, because the demands of meeting sales targets will outweigh the need to learn about the new sales program.

You can give many reasons for the failure of the above training but it will ultimately come down to this: The training is not effective, and both the learner and the training team are to blame for it.

What makes a learning effective? To my mind there are three factors: Intent, Content, and Present. If you want your learning to be effective the intent has to be there, and it starts right from the top. The senior leadership must see the value in the training and take an active interest in ensuring its success - not just in thought, but in deed. Very often, the senior leadership takes a dim view of having a training mechanism in place, instead relying on the middle management to coach their reports. Which is okay, provided the senior leadership ensures that the leaders are held accountable for their reports' performance. If it is the training team that delivers the training, not only should the training team be held responsible for training effectiveness, but the relevant support should be made available to them to develop and deliver an effective training.

Content plays an important role in training effectiveness. The adage "Content is King" is not without reason. The better training content there is, the better are the chances of trainers delivering it effectively and the trainees assimilating the training content. By better content, I mean content that is easy to understand and allows the learner to acquire the necessary skill level (or meets the learning objective in Instructional Design parlance).

The intent is there. The content is in place. And yet things can go hopelessly wrong if the content is not presented in the right manner. There is no perfect method of delivering training content, the diverse learning audiences and needs alone are sufficient to ensure that the perfect delivery method remains an aberration, but certain methods lend themselves better in certain situations. One fatal flaw mistake organizations frequently make is having the subject matter experts (SMEs) be the training content designers and/or presenters. Don't get me wrong, but a SME, unless she is trained in Instructional Design and/or Training Delivery, is the worst person to teach your learning audience. There is a reason why doctors treat ill people. The same reasons hold true when presenting a training, and it cannot be done by a person who is not a trainer.

Applying the Learning: I recall a somewhat humorous incident when I my uncle introduced automated financial accounting in his business. Prior to that, his accountant would do everything my hand and calculator. The accountant was trained on how to make entries in the new accounting system and he was very happy because it saved a lot of time for him. So imagine my uncle's surprise when the accountant took copious printouts of the balance sheets and started tabulating the entries on his trusty old calculator! There was effort and money that went into the training venture and it looked a waste, till that time at least. It took some convincing for the accountant to realize that what he was doing was redundant.

The incident above may be funny, but if you own an organization, the cost and the effort calculation will somewhat temper the humor. Yes, learning is meaningless if there is a lack of intent from everyone involved. Yes, it will not be effective if it is not designed, developed, and delivered properly. But nothing will defeat the objective of learning more if the learning that is delivered is not applied in real life. I can understand the reasons behind why this happens. To many of us, learning was something we did when we went to school and college and we did not apply the learning gained in real life to a large extent. Workplace training is different however, and in these times of instant gratification, managers and leadership want to see immediate effect of the training that was delivered.

There is no magic formula for this however, apart from a consistent feedback mechanism from the training team and encouragement from the leadership. The training team needs to know what is it that is stopping the learners from applying what they learned in real life so that the next wave of training will address these issues. The leadership on the other hand needs to ensure that their reports work (perhaps) out of their comfort zones to adapt to what they learned in the training.

The advantage of a learning culture should now be apparent. A learning organization pursues continuous improvement, sets high standards, and is much more adaptable to the changing market conditions. It inculcates a sense of belonging among its employees and encourages them to find newer and better ways of getting things done. Yes, mistakes will happen. But a learning organization will look at them as growth opportunities, rather than moments of regret.

Before closing, I would like to point out one thing that is worse than an organization that does not have a learning culture. Actually, it is the worst that an organization can do to itself. And that is an organization that pretends to have a learning culture. Such an organization will live in its bubble of comfort, where everything is as it should be - until the bubble bursts, and it will be painful.

Which is not so say that bad times cannot befall learning organizations, but they will be better prepared for it. So a learning organization will probably say - "Okay, try me again". An organization that does not have a learning culture will probably say - "I wish I had done that..." or better still "Let's try this now". An organization that pretends to be a learning organization however, will only have a question - "Why me?"

Like I said before, you don't need to own a company to make a learning organization. It can be anything - your company, your business unit, your team, even you yourself. If you are not a learning organization and want to become one, it is very much possible. But remember - a learning culture cannot be acquired overnight. It takes time and effort. That and an honest commitment.

However, if you are among those organizations that pretend to have a learning culture, and there are plenty of them around (jingoism always sounds good), then nothing or no one can make you a learning organization. Worse still, you will probably not know it, and when you do, the bad news is it will be too late. The good news is you will take your first step towards being a learning organization.

Hopefully, you will choose (or have already chosen) to learn, and continue learning, and learn from your learning, and apply your learning. That is what learning culture is about. That is what a learning organization is about.

Is Your Organization Learning? PART II

I asked a question in part I: Does your organization have a learning culture?

If you can honestly answer this question with a YES, I would say good for you. If you can honestly answer this question with a NO or a MAYBE then congratulations, you are on your way to becoming a learning organization.

But if you cannot answer the question honestly, then I have bad news - no amount of training budget is going to make your organization a learning organization.

Why is a learning organization necessary? Well the way I look at it, learning and development has undergone a huge metamorphosis over the last couple of decades. The advent of Internet and social media mean that we are exposed to a huge amount of information. The opportunity for learning has gone up manifold, so much so that learning is now becoming a continuous process (which is why you see 45-50 year olds taking up MBA ) as opposed to being a stage in life earlier (finish your degree, get a job, retire).

This availability of information plays a crucial role in leveling the playing field. Earlier, businesses enjoyed a competitive advantage by doing things in isolation. Now because of the openness of information, "trade secrets" are gradually falling into the category of "worst kept". So if you are in a particular business you cannot expect your competitor not to have an idea of your business, because then they would not be competitors in the first place. So assuming that there is this giant pool of information from which anyone can draw, how do you ensure that your organization maintains its competitive advantage? I believe that learning organizations are best poised to cash in on opportunities that come their way.

So if an organization was a learning organization, which means it incorporated a learning culture, how would it be different?

I will answer this question in part III.

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Is Your Organization Learning? PART I

Is your company/business unit/department/team (let's call them all organizations) a learning organization?

If I was to ask this question in a conclave comprising the senior leadership of an organization, I suspect a majority of them would answer with a vehement YES.

"Yes! We are a learning organization".

If I was to ask them how, they would typically respond with how training is given focus as a part of the organization strategy, how the leadership strives to ensure that every member of the staff continuously strives to upgrades his or her skills.

Then I would ask the trickiest, and perhaps the most important, question - How much time does the organization allocate for learning and development per employee and what is the return on that?

The second part of the above question is where it falls flat. You see, there is no definite answer. Don't get me wrong, there are organizations where employees have training and development as a percentage of their KRAs, and yet the impact of training is minimal. Then there are organizations where most people learn on the job, and yet they have a workforce that is trained and very effective.

Why is it so? I think the answer lies in one phrase - a learning culture.

To be learning organizations, companies need to inculcate a learning culture. Before you accuse me of throwing jargon at you, let me define learning culture. I would say that a learning culture is an environment which facilitates learning opportunities, ensures effective learning from these learning opportunities, and applies the learning gained to become a better organization.

Time for me to ask you a question again: Does your organization have a learning culture?

Let's discuss the answer in the next part.

About this Blog

More than a decade in the field and not a blog to show for it, I decided that I should share what I learned from Instructional Design over these years. This blog is a collection of my experiences, observations, and opinions on the same.